Posted By:	George Schire
Posted On:	Tuesday May 22, 2012 at 10:22 AM
Message: Wasn't trying to change "this one" Steve. Thought we were all just having a discussion and sharing opinions. It does seem that some are on the fence as to what the true definition of an orphan car is, as the varying opinions reveal. Sometimes discussions can go back and forth with points being made. I assure you, I'm not saying my opinion is right, only the way I (and some others apparently) define an orphan. I don't think that is being obstinate. I'll move on (to another thread) and leave this "dead horse" to rest in peace. :)

Go back to Diecast Forums - Forum 24 – Diecast Zone

Message thread:

In the current issue (#95) of Hemmings, "Classic Cars" magazine... by George Schire #42849

While GM and Chrysler could revive those names (since they own the names), chances are very slim by Lawrence Kalfayan #42849.1

Lawrence, though you make some good logic, I'm afraid I don't by George Schire #42849.1.1

Ummm car names resurrected...... by Phil Realmuto #42849.1.2

I was referring to the name of an entire make; not model names within that make or marque. I agree by Lawrence Kalfayan #42849.1.2.1

OOOOH sorry my mistake! I didn't catch that by Phil Realmuto #42849.1.2.1.1

"QUESTION"...What is an "ORPHAN CAR?".... by john engelman #42849.2

John...your thinking is the same as I've always thought with regard to what an Orpan car is. But by George Schire #42849.2.1

If You're Wrong Then I Am Too -- I Understand the Definition As You Do (EOM) by Ed Stutz #42849.2.2

"CORRECT"....Let's take a child for instance...he can't be an orphan if he no longer exists, but if by john engelman #42849.2.2.1

So Jeep would be an orphan who got adopted? (EOM) by Tom Joyce #42849.2.2.1.1

I look at it this way......... by Jerry Gorsuch #42849.2.3

So Jerr...how do you apply YOUR logic to Studebaker, Packard, American Motors/Nash/Hudson/Rambler/, by john engelman #42849.2.3.1

John, the parents of the "orphans" are the Motor Car Divisions, i.e., by Jerry Gorsuch #42849.2.3.1.1

John, you're wrong as far as the experts say. According to them an orphan is a brand no longer in by Steve Kiraly #42849.2.4

Well Steve and Jerry, you and anyone else who agrees with you, will never convince me of your logic. by George Schire #42849.2.4.1

George, it's not our logic, it's just the way it is. You can disagree all you want, but ..... I'm by Steve Kiraly #42849.2.4.1.1

LOL Steve...why is it "just the way it is?" Because the perverbial "they" say so? by George Schire #42849.2.4.1.1.1

OMG, George, it's not fun when you get so obstinate. It IS THE WAY IT IS because that's how orphans by Steve Kiraly #42849.2.4.1.1.1.1

Wasn't trying to change "this one" Steve. Thought we were all just having by George Schire #42849.2.4.1.1.1.1.1

New News  ·  List & Reviews  ·  Legacy Motors  ·  Auctions  ·  Forums  ·  Polls  ·  Features  ·  Register  ·  FAQs  ·  Clubs

Copyright © 2013 Gennera Knab and Diecast Zone