Posted By:	Al Dorado
Posted On:	Monday December 3, 2018 at 11:37 AM
Message: For me it's a tie. I luv them both.

Go back to Diecast Forums – The Lounge – Diecast Zone

Message thread:

PICs: Which '58? Buick or Cadillac by John Bono #39678

Buick. That Cadillac looks like front and back halves of two different cars. (EOM) by Barry Levittan #39678.1

Buick. (EOM) by Brian Cox #39678.2

BUICK for me. I thought the 58 Caddy got uglier than the 57, and then hit horrific by George Schire #39678.3

Once more George you prove my point (thanks!) You hate the 1959 Cadillac but thousands..... by Christopher Moroni #39678.3.1

And you Christopher also prove MY point. You insist that people bought cars to by George Schire #39678.3.1.1

George, I 100% agree with everything you just noted. My only point(s) to all of this.... by Christopher Moroni #39678.3.1.1.1

Thanks Christopher, I think we'er good. I would love to sit and chat cars with you sometime and by George Schire #39678.3.1.1.1.1

.... yeah, one or the other but not both at the same time. LoL (EOM) by Christopher Moroni #39678.3.1.1.1.1.1

Hmmm, never tried ice-cream and beer together. We could be on to the next big thing. :) (EOM) by George Schire #39678.3.1.1.1.1.1.1

Hmmm, never tried ice-cream and beer together. We could be on to the next big thing. :) (EOM) by George Schire #39678.3.1.1.1.1.1.2

IMHO the car you drive should reflect your economic status. by Barry Levittan #39678.3.1.2

Well then ... I drive Cadillac Escalade by Dennis Mong #39678.3.1.2.1

Barry, I have no problem with your rational as long as by George Schire #39678.3.1.2.2

Buick! (EOM) by John Merritt #39678.4

Buick! The rear end of the Caddy takes away from an otherwise good looking car. (EOM) by Tim Kubiak #39678.5

Cadillac by a very small margin. (EOM) by David Vandermeer #39678.6

+1 (EOM) by Terence Slekar #39678.6.1

Hate the Buick & the Caddy rear but like the Caddy front. (EOM) by Bruce Parsons #39678.7

Pass ... What else you got ? (EOM) by Dennis Mong #39678.8

+1 (EOM) by Frank Kocour #39678.8.1

To be honest I think they're both design disasters, however... by John Roberts #39678.9

Agreed. 1955 and 1956 were the high points of the decade IMO. (EOM) by Ed Glorius #39678.9.1

I was born in ' 56 ... I love the '55 & '56 Bowtie Offerings (EOM) by Dennis Mong #39678.9.2

Cadillac (EOM) by George Burgess #39678.10

A '50's Buick without Venti-Ports? Give me the Caddy, please. (EOM) by Michael Rodriguez #39678.11

Cadillac, but give me the Series 62 rear end. (EOM) by Ed Glorius #39678.12

Buick. (EOM) by Bob Jackman #39678.13

Caddy because I had a 58 Buick (EOM) by Ron Dietrich #39678.14

Sounds like there's a story there somewhere! (EOM) by Rick Thompson #39678.14.1

It was a great road car making weekends between Camp Lejuene and Cleveland - by Ron Dietrich #39678.14.1.1

Buick. (EOM) by Sal Lomma #39678.15

I am not a fan of either one. I think that Buick by Dick Johnson #39678.16

Buick. The Caddy stole the Chevy front end. (EOM) by Gary Rockwood #39678.16.1

Red 1958 Buick Limited Convertible by Joseph Sturges #39678.17

Pass on both. (EOM) by Randy Portwood #39678.18

For me it's a tie. I luv them both. (EOM) by Al Dorado #39678.19

Buick. I never liked the tail end of the '58 Eldo. (EOM) by John Bono #39678.20

New News  ·  List & Reviews  ·  Legacy Motors  ·  Auctions  ·  Forums  ·  Polls  ·  Features  ·  Register  ·  FAQs  ·  Clubs

Copyright © 2018 Legacy Diecast Models and Diecast Zone